• Home
  • About
  • Advertising/PR
  • Contact
  • Login
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Meet Penny

Raising a family with sense on cents

  • Family
  • Finance
  • Fun
  • Work at Home
  • Giving & Serving
  • Shop

in Finance

How to Negotiate with Credit Card Companies

Share & Help Me Grow

In January of 2007, we filed for bankruptcy, and it was a mistake. We carried tremendous guilt, feeling we had left God’s will looking for an easy out, and the monthly payment for the Chapter 13 bankruptcy was still more than we could bear. We ended up contacting our trustee and leaving the bankruptcy early.

However, the debt remained. In fact, the collectors began demanding payment in full and they wanted it NOW.

Since we had received an income tax refund, we decided to do some research and chose to negotiate with the credit card companies ourselves. All glory to God… we were able to reduce a five figure debt by 60% and pay it off in ten months.

She successfully negotiated a five figure debt with collectors and paid it off in less than one year.

If you are caught between phone calls from debt collectors and annoying “final notice” letters in the mail, consider these tips that might help you pay off your debts quickly.

Know the statute of limitations

First, research the statute of limitations on your type of debt for your state because your debts might be un-claimable by the collection agency.

Each state has a statute of limitations on credit card debt. In our state, if we had not made a payment in three years, the debt was considered un-claimable and it had to be forgiven. However, our bankruptcy trustee was making tiny payments to keep the debt active.

Know who holds your debt

Next, understand who exactly is claiming to own your debt. After several months of being unable to solicit payments on your account, a credit card company will sell your account to a collection agency. Some agencies are parented by the credit card company while others are third parties.

Once your debt is sold, the credit card company is no longer a part of the debt repayment process. They have sold the debt for a portion of what you owed (10% to 20%), writing off the remainder of the balance as “bad debt,” and received a tax credit for the unpaid balance rom the government. The collector is now in charge and will try to solicit payment for the complete balance… even though they only paid for part.

Have a plan before you negotiate

Negotiating with the credit card company

If you are within the statute of limitations and the credit card company still holds your debt, consider this plan…

1) Call the credit card companies and tell them you are under a financial hardship to see if they can adjust your interest rate. Then, pay the minimum payment. DO NOT tell them your plan.

2) Start saving cash in a sock. Not in the bank. Every deposit will be tracked should you need to file bankruptcy. Under bankruptcy, you will not be able to have a savings account nor pay a tithe or make charitable contributions.

3) When you have accumulated enough money, start negotiating with the credit card company. It is completely up to you whether or not you continue to pay them minimum payments or want to deal with the incessant phone calls for three to six months, but patience is your friend. You really want them to be ready to negotiate.

She successfully negotiated a five figure debt with collectors and paid it off in less than one year.

If you choose to negotiate directly with the credit card company, you need to have enough cash ready to pay off the amount you agree upon. Most will want at least 50%. The rest is written off as bad debt, and you have to pay taxes on the remaining portion but your credit report will state that the debt was cancelled as agreed.

Negotiating with a collection agency

If your debt has been sold to a collector, do not fret. We discovered negotiating with a collection agency was actually easier. Since the collector only paid the credit card company 10 to 20% for your debt, you can begin the negotiation process for a much lower rate. You can start by offering them 20% and negotiate back and forth.

If they act like that is ridiculous, make the agency aware that you know they paid a small fraction of what they are asking and request that they call back when they are willing to negotiate. You might need to press hard to speak with someone who has the authority to write a contract with you, but if you find the right person, the process can move quickly.

Once you reach an agreement, have the total amount and payments placed in a contract. They will then give you about nine months to pay off the negotiated amount. Again, the balance is written off and you have to pay taxes on it, but the deal is done. The debt is gone. Nothing remains but the ugly mark on your credit report.

Keep track of the details

As you work through this process, keep a log of each time you call the company or each time they call you. Write down the incoming phone number, the name of the representative, the time, and exact details about your conversation. Always write down what you offered and how they countered your offer.

Overall, if you are willing to negotiate and have a substantial downpayment to place towards the new contract, these companies will work with you. Their job is to make money. Your job is to pay them off with as little as possible and never owe them another penny for as long as you live.

Have you ever negotiated a debt? What did you learn about the process that might help others?

Filed Under: Finance Tagged With: Bankruptcy, credit cards, debt

About Tabitha

Hi! I'm Tabitha! But, I bet you expected someone named "Penny." Long story made short, Penny is the coupon binder I started in 2010 when we were totally broke... as in BANKRUPT. Now, as a mom of five, I make 6-figures a year working at home and share ways to help you move from penny to profit while you raise a family with sense on cents.

« Preparing Meals for Gluten Free Friends
How to Save Money on Data Plans #ItsANewDayForData »

Comments

  1. fiona tosh says

    March 3, 2018 at 7:02 am

    any help in reducing and not hiding from my responsibilities is appreciated – very frightened as been put through a lot and the last experience was a controlling partner pyschologically and financially

    Reply
  2. fiona tosh says

    March 3, 2018 at 7:02 am

    any help? in reducing and not hiding from my responsibilities is appreciated – very frightened as been put through a lot and the last experience was a controlling partner pyschologically and financially

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. How to Make Money Blogging - Meet Penny says:
    September 27, 2015 at 5:43 pm

    […] filing for bankruptcy at one point but then changing our minds and paying off those debts through negotiating with collectors. For a little over a decade, we hovered around poverty level but during that process, I learned how […]

    Reply
  2. 25 Days of Budget Transformations Day 15: How to Negotiate Credit Card Debt | Passionate Penny Pincher says:
    February 18, 2016 at 6:01 pm

    […] Ready for a new 25 day series? This month our 25 Days Series is aimed at inspiring you to tackle your family budget, with amazing budget transformation stories and helpful tips to keep you on track. I love the stories we’re sharing here! […]

    Reply
  3. 5 Myths about Bankruptcy and the Truth from Someone who Survived Chapter 13 - Meet Penny says:
    May 14, 2016 at 10:25 am

    […] the source of your information is unbiased. And find ways to increase your income to have a way to negotiate with creditors on your […]

    Reply
  4. Sharing Our Finance Story at Inspiring Mom Bloggers Summit - Meet Penny says:
    January 20, 2017 at 11:01 am

    […] I share our successes and failures freely here on this blog and have witnessed God turn our poverty into purpose. He has […]

    Reply
  5. How to Budget with a Free Budget Template - Meet Penny says:
    March 9, 2018 at 4:46 pm

    […] you want to play hardball with the credit card companies, don’t forget that you can also negotiate with creditors yourself. I have done it and survived. You can do it […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Christian Easter Activity Pack with over 35 activities. Great for preK-K.

Recent Posts

  • Easter Story Snack Mix for Kids
  • What to Pack in a Operation Christmas Child Shoebox
  • Jelly Bean Gospel – An Object Lesson on Salvation
  • Financial Goals for Teens
  • Paper Mache Cone Angel Craft
  • Replacing the Lies (Self Esteem Object Lesson)
  • Back to School
  • Homeschool
  • Homeschool Curriculum

Have you met Penny?

Hi! I'm Tabitha. Yes, I know that you expected someone named "Penny," but there is a bit of a story … [READ MORE]

As an Amazon Associate I make a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. You can read more about my affiliate relationships in my Disclosure Policy.
Advertising/PR | Privacy Policy | Disclosure | Terms | Affiliates | Contact

Copyright © 2026 · Market theme by Restored 316